AC/UNU
Millennium Project
Global
Challenges Facing Humanity
7.
Rich-Poor Gap
How can ethical
market economies be encouraged to help reduce the gap between rich and
poor?
Developing countries contribute half of the world’s $62-trillion annual
economic growth. Previous economic growth has led to dramatic increases in life
expectancy, primary school enrolments, access to safe drinking water and sanitation,
and decreases in infant mortality. If this continues, the World Bank estimates
that those living on $1 a day could fall from 29% in 1990 to 10% by 2015, even
with increasing population in the poorest regions. However, increasing oil prices
and deteriorating environmental conditions make this difficult; yet the majority
of countries are increasing their economic freedoms, which should increase future
income. Currently, income gaps are widening within 53 countries, home to 80%
of the world’s population. About 2.5 billion people (40% of the world)
live on $2 or less per day.
Foreign direct investment, representing the largest source of external finance
for developing countries, increased 29% worldwide in 2005, reaching $897 billion.
Official development assistance from OECD countries reached a record $106.5
billion and is projected to reach $130 billion by 2010. WTO members agreed to
eliminate all agriculture export subsidies by 2013. According to UNDP, industrial
countries’ agricultural subsidies cost developing countries $72 billion
per year, about 70% of all international development assistance; hence the WTO
agreement could be one of the most effective ways to increase developing countries’
income.
The IMF estimates that the global economy grew 4.8% in 2005 while the population
grew 1.15%, increasing per capita income by 3.65%. The annual increase in per
capita income in developing countries has averaged about 2% since 1990 (however,
without India and China, the average has decreased), and the effect on poverty
varied widely. East and South Asia grew the fastest, while sub-Saharan Africa’s
poverty doubled party due to high birth rates, corruption, armed conflicts,
poor governance, environmental degradation, poor health conditions, and lack
of education. The entry into force of the UN Convention against Corruption might
help.
China and India, with the second and fourth largest PPP GDP in the world, are
major engines reducing world poverty, yet their high-tech and low wages will
make future trade-led economic growth difficult for other developing countries.
Ethical market economies require a “level playing field” guaranteed
by an honest judicial system and by governments that provide political stability,
a chance to participate in local development decisions, business incentives
to comply with social and environmental goals, fairer trade, a healthy investment
climate, and access to land, capital, and information. Since capital flows to
profit potential, ethical activities have to be shown to be profitable and corporations
have to be held accountable.
Challenge 7 will be addressed seriously when market economy abuses and corruption
by companies and governments are intensively prosecuted, when the number of
people living on less than $2 per day drops by 75%, and when the development
gap—by all definitions—declines in 8 out of 10 years. A strategic
plan for a global partnership between the rich and poor should be created and
implemented that uses the strength of free markets and rules based on global
ethics to reduce the disparities that otherwise might grow enough to increase
migration of the poor to richer regions, increasing conflicts. The strategy
should also include massive investments into tele-education and tele-work, replacing
welfare attitudes with entrepreneurial spirit, reinforced by expanded microcredit
mechanisms coupled with technical assistance, while using state welfare in states
with little private sector. Many people will have to become self-employed, seeking
personal markets rather than non-existent jobs.
The 70,000 transnational corporations with over 690,000 foreign affiliates
(almost half of which are in developing countries) should be encouraged to increase
their efforts to address income gaps within and between countries. Improve mechanisms
to collect fees to address income gaps, improve global public goods, improve
global governance systems, and internalize current externalities. These might
include international transaction and transportation fees and an environmental
footprint tax in addition to carbon trading for nations.
Regional Considerations
Africa: Sub-Saharan Africa
produces 2% of the global economy, 44% of people there live on less that $1 a
day, and the MDGs are not likely to be met unless the region creates cultures
that are more scientifically oriented, produce more favorable climates for foreign
investment, reinforce entrepreneurial spirit rather than jealousy, increase confidence
in an ethical market economy, foster environmental stewardship, encourage small
business, and fight corruption. The G-8 agreed on a comprehensive plan to support
Africa’s progress and committed to double aid to Africa by 2010 by at least
$25 billion extra per year, while canceling external debt for 18 of the most indebted
countries. To create the necessary jobs for Africa’s growing population,
economic growth has to increase by 6–7% on a sustained basis until 2020.
Asia and Oceania: The region produces
about a third of world’s output and has two-thirds of the world’s
poor. India and China are engines for poverty reduction in the region, with 7%
and 9% economic growth respectively and a total of 200 million entrepreneurs.
Water and energy shortages in China, plus widening rural-urban income gaps, threaten
future growth, yet its strategy of socialist political control with capitalist
economic policies should be considered by other countries with responsible leadership.
Many Asians believe that ethical markets are created by the combination of spiritual
and material development. The keys to economic growth in the Middle East are greater
economic freedom, the resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the rule
of law, increased literacy, and small business development.
Europe: The combination of high unemployment,
aging population, and expensive public services is not sustainable without increasing
numbers of immigrants and more tele-entrepreneurs among the next generation of
retired Europeans. EU enlargement continues to expand ethical markets and harmonize
legal systems. Eastern Europe is the world’s most active region in enacting
economic reforms. The EU pledged at least 0.56% of its GNI to aid developing countries
by 2010.
Latin America: Latin America has the
largest rich-poor gap. Because governments advocating free-market approaches did
not make serious progress on income gaps and social justice, some countries in
the region are moving toward more state-centered policies, nationalizing resources,
and creating new regional agreements, such the Petrocaribe of 14 Caribbean nations
with Venezuela for lower oil prices. Distribution of the means of production and
land tenure must change, with the participation of lower-income people in all
phases of development projects, reinforced by an educated middle class and an
active civil society.
North America: Small businesses employ
half of all private-sector workers and create two-thirds of the net new jobs in
the United States. With 4.6% of world’s population, the U.S. produces over
20% of the world’s wealth. Lobbying and corruption challenge the development
of more ethical market economies.
Graph: Share
of People Living on Less than $1 a Day (%)

Source:
World Bank, World Development Indicators 2006
You are invited to participate in
updating and improving this challenge. Please click
here for the online suvey form.
Millennium
Project Homepage